Loading...

    sorted by publishing date

    Last Edited: 10 hours ago

    Futur: Der deutsche Forschungsdialog1December 2000 - November 2005

    Futur: The German Research Dialogue

    Which research trajectories can serve future societal needs and open up new areas of scientific interest? In 2001, the participatory future dialogue “Futur” was launched as one of the first national foresight processes in Germany on behalf of the Federal Ministry of Education and Research (BMBF) with the mission to address this question. In particular, the project aimed to identify future priorities for research funding. Futur can be viewed as the third phase of national foresight activities in Germany, following an initial foresight study published in 1993 and German Delphi surveys between 1993 and 1998.

    However, the underlying objectives and methodology differed from those of the preceding processes: Futur was designed to inform research-funding decisions in Germany. Compared with earlier processes, Futur did not focus exclusively on scientific and technological aspects but also considered broader political and societal developments relevant to science policy such as demographic change and the resulting societal needs. In terms of methodology, Futur was based on an interdisciplinary dialogue and thus contributed to the advancement of participatory foresight methodology in Germany. 

    Futur established a network of up to 1,500 experts from different sectors of the economy and society. Thy were involved through various formats, including workshops, focus groups and online activities. During the first phase in early summer 2001, participants attended an initial workshop series. On the basis of the workshops, the Futur consortium was able to identify more than 60 suggestions for topics that could, were expected to, or were seen as desirable to shape the future of society. These were presented at the Futur conference in September 2001. Of these, 25 topics were selected, and detailed profiles were developed for each. Informed by the expertise of various commissions and based on the Futur guiding principles, the BMBF selected 12 topics. 

    The Futur guiding principles were:
    - Societal need and real-world relevance
    - Interdisciplinarity
    - Relevance as a research topic
    - Potential for further development and consolidation

    In order to deepen the understanding of the remaining topics and especially observe new potentials for research, focus groups were formed. They participated in futures workshops, held in-person meetings and virtual discussions. A further prioritisation stage followed, and the BMBF again selected a set of topics for the next steps of the process. Next, the focus groups participated in scenario workshops and created concrete scenarios for different societal areas, using 2020 as the time horizon. One of the first results was the adoption of the four Futur lead visions by the BMBF as guidelines for research funding, with BMBF implementation teams responsible for their realisation. 

    These four inital lead visions for future research were:
    1. Healthy and Vital throughout Life by Prevention
    2. Creating Open Access to Tomorrow's World of Learning
    3. Understanding Thought Processes
    4. Living in a Networked World: individual and secure

    Finally, the process was evaluated by a survey of participants as well as by an international foresight expert commission. They considered Futur as leading onto the right trajectory and recommended the continuation of the process. The project’s results were publicly presented in the first report in the summer of 2002. As Futur was designed in a way that allowed initially deprioritised topics to be picked up again, five additional candidates for lead visions were developed in 2004 and 2005 and the process was again evaluated by international experts. Futur continued until 2005 and was subsequently followed by several BMBF-Foresight processes such as BMBF Foresight Cycles I and II. 

    List (incomplete) of publications in English:

    Banthien, H., Cuhls, K., and Ludewig, N. (2004), “Introduction of Futur - the German Research Dialogue”. https://publica.fraunhofer.de/handle/publica/345085

    Cuhls, K. (2003), From forecasting to foresight processes—new participative foresight activities in Germany. J. Forecast., 22: 93-111. https://doi.org/10.1002/for.848 

    Cuhls, K., Georghiou, L. (2004), Evaluating a participative foresight process: ‘Futur - the German research dialogue’, Research Evaluation, 13 (3): 143–153, https://doi.org/10.3152/147154404781776437

    Posted on: 19/11/2026

    Last Edited: a year ago

    Report on the assessment of the digital competencies needed in the Romanian civil serviceFebruary 2025

    Taking into account relevant policies at the national and European Union levels

    Romania’s public administration faces deep-rooted structural challenges that hinder the development of digital competencies and slow progress in both digital transformation and human resources management (HRM) reforms. While digital competencies are essential to achieving Romania’s public sector modernization goals, they are not a standalone solution. In this context, the government of Romania, assisted by the World Bank through the Technical Support Instrument (TSI), aims to develop a General Digital Competence Framework for Civil Servants.

    This report if one of the outputs of the TSI project; its goal is to identify the digital competencies necessary at the intersection of Romania’s digital transformation and HRM reform agendas, laying the groundwork for a more capable and future-ready public administration. The report employs a comprehensive multi-layered analysis, incorporating: a top-down review of national and EU strategies, policies, and regulations; a bottom-up analysis of job descriptions, focus groups, interviews, and working groups; international best practices in public sector digital competencies; and a foresight perspective to anticipate future digital skill needs.

    Chapter VI | Foresight: fit-for-future digital roles in the public administration describes the foresight exercise carried out by Institutul de Prospectiva and the World Bank, which was aimed at ensuring that the proposed digital competency framework will remain future-ready, enabling civil servants to navigate digital transformation, deliver citizen-centric services, and address complex policy challenges with agility and innovation. The process was meant to inform the definition of specific digital roles that are needed in the future, but also to allow the formulation of recommendations regarding the general digital competencies of public administration employees.

    The foresight methodology utilized horizon scanning and scenarios (both explorative and normative), as essential tools in helping policymakers navigate uncertainty by exploring various probable and/or desirable futures. This foresight exercise focused on the year 2032, a timeframe suited for significant structural transformation in public administration, allowing for the development and maturity of complex digital systems.

    In terms of process, the scenario-building process was based on an iterative consultation process. It built on inputs developed by the foresight team from Institutul de Prospectiva and was progressively refined through three online working sessions with international experts from the World Bank and the Joint Research Centre (JRC) and a final in-person workshop with local experts from the public administration and the private sector in Romania.
    The figure below provides a concise overview of the scenario-building steps.

    📌The Baseline Scenario “Romanian Digital Administration in 2032” provides a ‘current paradigm’ case: It takes the current Romanian strategic documents in the field of digital transformation as a starting point. It assumes that the key goals set in these
    documents are generally met by 2032. The logic is the following: assuming Romania’s current digitalization paradigm (and
    associated digital roles) turn out mostly as planned, what is the gap between this best-case baseline and the digital society scenarios for 2032?

    📌The Context Scenario about the “Digital society in Romania in 2032” is an exploratory scenario, meaning it describes a probable future rather than one driven by a deliberate vision of a desirable future society. The core scenario integrates high-impact, high-probability trends - or drivers of change -identified in the initial horizon scanning phase. While these drivers describe the evolution of the European and global contexts, their advancement has been partially adjusted to reflect specific conditions in Romania. In addition to the core scenario, four other narratives were built around drivers of change previously identified as having high impact as well as a rather high degree of uncertainty. These new dimensions largely complement rather than challenge the core scenario.

    📌The five Aspirational Scenarios 2032 describe visions regarding the digital transformation of the Romanian public administration, going beyond the trajectory set in the baseline scenario. They examine a range of potential paths/options that could contribute, individually or in various combinations, to a more ambitious and impactful digital transformation in the public administration. Each scenario revolves around a key dimension. Primarily, these dimensions emerge from Romania’s current policy discourse and strategic documents, where they are often mentioned but with limited precision or commitment. Additionally, they reflect elements of the context scenario, incorporating anticipated societal developments by 2032, as
    well as digital trends and paradigm shifts observed in public administrations in the EU and worldwide.

    A list of key digital roles follows the baseline and aspirational scenarios, outlining the expertise civil servants need to bring them to life. These roles do not distinguish between in-house and outsourced expertise, as that remains a separate decision.



    Posted on: 11/08/2025

    Last Edited: a year ago

    Agustín ALEMÁN GONZÁLEZ1

    Think exponentially, act incrementally.

    Posted on: 09/05/2025

    Last Edited: a year ago

    Digital Transformation in the Romanian Public Administration1November 2024 - February 2025

    Scenarios and Associated Digital Roles

    This foresight study aims to support the design of a robust and adaptable digital competency framework that aligns with the long-term strategic priorities of the public administration in Romania. Additionally, it seeks to ensure the framework remains future-ready, enabling civil servants to navigate digital transformation, deliver citizen-centric services, and address complex policy challenges with agility and innovation.


    The foresight methodology utilized horizon scanning and scenarios (both explorative and normative) as essential tools in strategic planning, helping organizations and policymakers navigate uncertainty by exploring various probable and/or desirable futures.

    This study focuses on the year 2032, a timeframe suited for structural transformation in public administration, allowing for the development and maturity of complex digital systems.

    The scenario-building process was based on inputs developed by the foresight team at Institutul de Prospectiva and was progressively refined through three online working sessions and a final in-person workshop.

    The figure below provides a concise overview of the scenario-building steps, followed by a detailed explanation of the characteristics and objectives of each scenario type.

    Posted on: 01/04/2025